✕

Abshir Abdi: The lawyer who knows too much

Crime and Justice
By David Odongo | Nov 16, 2026

 

Advocate Abshir Ahmedsadak Abdi (centre) reunites with former LSK president Eric Theuri and lawyer Ndegwa Njiru after returning following his abduction, at Milimani Law Courts in Nairobi.  [David Gichuru, Standard]

The white Toyota Premio lay on its side in a drainage ditch along Muchai Road, off Ngong Road, like a bird with a broken neck. The lawyers at Mugeria, Lempaa and Kariuki Advocates would later write, in a complaint letter to DCI Director Amin Mohamed Ibrahim, that it all began with a batch of mobile phones. Between June 15 and July 15, 2024, Ahmed Ali Mohamed took possession of electronic goods worth Sh618,000 from Ahmed Abdi Hassan on a promise to pay after resale.

He never paid. Hassan reported the fraud at Pangani Police Station under OB number 03/08/10/04/2024, and the Office of the Director of Public Prosecutions at Makadara recommended charges under Section 313 of the Penal Code for obtaining goods by false pretences. Had the story ended there, it would have been one of hundreds of small fraud cases that pass through Nairobi’s commercial courts every year. But Ahmed Ali Mohamed was not an ordinary small-time swindler. At least, that is what Hassan’s affidavits say. The case was mentioned in court more than ten times, and each time it failed to proceed.

The line Hassan’s lawyers would later put in writing now reads like a prophecy: “From the foregoing, it is evident that a plan had been hatched to intimidate us to withdraw the matter and ATPU was to be used as the tool.” The first time the blade of that tool truly showed itself was on October 9, 2025. Ahmedsadak Abdi Abshir remembered that day. Two men—Siyad Mohamed and Abdirahman—first posed as employees of the estate’s management company to get through the gate of his compound in Nairobi. Once the gate was open, he was handed over to waiting ATPU officers.

Abshir later stated in his affidavit that in the interrogation room at ATPU headquarters, he was told “in a harsh and intimidating manner” that he had to prevail over the accused and have the case withdrawn before October 28, 2025. He refused. The threats then escalated to the highest level: if he did not comply, the ATPU would craft terrorism-related charges against him and keep him detained at ATPU so that he would not attend court.

“The threats were followed with insults in Somali language,” Abshir’s affidavit reads. On October 11, he was released unconditionally with a P52 form. But before he could even clear the ATPU gate, he was re-arrested. On October 13, he was taken to Kahawa Law Courts, where the investigating officer, Mr. Some, sought custodial orders. In a rare moment of judicial pushback, prosecutors declined to approve the miscellaneous application. He was released unconditionally later that day. Hassan’s own experience was no better. He stated in his affidavit that ATPU and NIS personnel picked him up, subjected him to “arm-twisting,” and coerced him to drop the charges.

On October 24, in an interview room at the ATPU offices in Upperhill, Siyad told Hassan, in the presence of investigating officer Karanja, that if he did not withdraw the case, he would be detained in the ATPU cells so that he would miss the October 29 court date. Abdirahman brandished a gun during the interview. Siyad continued threatening him, saying that as long as the case remained active in court, Hassan was “in a big hole” and “he will die.” Siyad concluded: “If I made Ahmedsadak Abshir to be arrested and he is an advocate he should imagine what he will do to him being a small person.”

The threats were made in Somali. The complaint letter is clear: present in the room was ATPU investigating officer Karanja. The questions the lawyers put to the DCI Director land like nails in the coffin of Kenya’s criminal justice system. Why are NIS officers leading ATPU interrogations? Why are NIS officers allowed to openly use ATPU facilities, including the white Nissan Patrol KAU 823V, to run intimidation errands? Why are they brandishing guns in interrogation rooms?

And the question that gets repeated—“Can citizens hire ATPU as private militia, mercenaries or mafia to undertake their illegal and unlawful activities like threatening Kenyans to withdraw cases in Court?”

Hassan also described a detail to the court that is more telling than any gun muzzle. ATPU officers “pleaded” with him to allow them to exploit his electronic gadgets and search his house. He declined and respectfully asked them to obtain a court order from Kahawa Law Courts. The lawyers asked in the complaint letter: why does the investigating officer want our clients to voluntarily consent to their phones being examined and their homes searched, instead of getting a court order as ATPU normally does? Is it that these investigations are being done off book or unofficially?

Law Society of Kenya members protest against the abduction of lawyer Abshir Abdi outside Milimani Law Courts in Nairobi. [David Gichuru, Standard]

Meanwhile, Abshir’s name began to appear in an entirely different narrative. In November 2026, Chief Inspector Vitalis Kibet, the Officer Commanding Station at the ATPU Nairobi Detachment, told Justice Alexander Muteti at the Milimani High Court that the ATPU had received intelligence in August 2025 about a ring of extortionists abusing counter-terrorism operations to solicit bribes from members of the public. Abshir and Hassan were alleged to be part of this network. Kibet said Abshir was arrested on October 9, 2025, at Diamond Park 2 Estate in South B over the alleged abduction of Ahmed Ali Mohamed—the defendant in the mobile phone fraud case himself. Same date. Same arrest.

Two opposite stories. In one version, Abshir was a witness snatched by the ATPU to force him to withdraw the case. In the other, he was the mastermind of an abduction, a member of a criminal network that exploited counter-terrorism agencies for extortion. Kibet told the court the network colluded with officers from the EACC, IPOA, the Judiciary, the National Police Service and the ODPP. “Once the subject was aware that there was a target who has obtained Kenyan identification by fraudulent means police role will be limited to arresting that person and then you extort,” he said.

Justice Muteti pressed: Are you saying that those who refuse to pay are arrested and taken to court on fabricated charges? “Yes, that is exactly what I have stated,” Kibet replied. On the morning of November 1, 2026, CCTV cameras on Muchai Road captured what happened next. A white Toyota Premio, registration KDL 356C, was blocked by a black Toyota Land Cruiser Prado TX and a double-cabin pickup. Men in tactical gear got out. Abshir ran toward a gate. One man grabbed him by the neck and pulled him down, others kicked him, and then they bundled him into the waiting SUV. His phone went dead.

His car was later found and towed to Kilimani Police Station. Abshir’s brother, Zakaria, stated in an affidavit filed at the High Court that he last saw his brother at about 4 a.m. on November 1, when armed men in tactical military clothing forced Abshir to kneel before bundling him into a black Prado TX. The family believes the abduction is directly connected to his role as a witness in the Makadara case. They say Abshir had previously received threats from individuals linked to the NIS, DCI, the Counter-Terrorism Bureau and the Kenya Defence Forces, warning him to withdraw from the case or face abduction and death.

He had reported the threats to senior security officials, but no action was taken. Justice Muteti ordered the heads of the security agencies—the NIS Director, the DCI Director, the Inspector General of Police, the Director of the Counter-Terrorism Bureau and the Director of Military Intelligence—to produce Abshir in court by 2:30 p.m. on November 4, “dead or alive.” ATPU officer Nicholas Kimanthi took the witness stand. He said he learned about the disappearance from social media at around 9 p.m. on November 3. The judge asked if he had made any inquiries. “I did not, my lord,” he said.

He added that Muchai Road fell under Kilimani jurisdiction, so the matter should be handled by DCI Kilimani. DCI Kilimani investigating officer Corporal Dennis Mwenda told the court they had retrieved CCTV footage showing a man trying to scale a wall, being subdued by three armed men and bundled into a vehicle. Abshir’s white Toyota Premio was taken to Kilimani Police Station for fingerprint and forensic examination. They made “verbal inquiries” and established that Abshir was not in custody in Nairobi or at any police station in the country. Kibet, the ATPU OCS, said something that silenced the courtroom: “I am the OCS, and from the date the subject disappeared, I have never come across his name in the Occurrence Book or the register.”

But the same officer confirmed under cross-examination that Abshir had indeed been arrested and detained at ATPU on October 9, 2025. Ahmed Ali Mohamed, the defendant in the fraud case, had also been arrested and detained at ATPU on October 24, 2025. Neither was charged. Both were released. The affidavit Abshir filed on November 13, 2025, now reads like a distress signal from another time. He was already asking the court to intervene against witness intimidation and to protect the witnesses in the case. He wrote that the threats were intended “to interfere with the criminal process and to defeat the administration of justice.” He asked the court to cancel the accused’s bail on the grounds that “intimidation and interference with witnesses is an affront to the administration of Justice and therefore a compelling reason to cancel bail.”

Almost a year after that affidavit was filed, he became the person who needed to be produced in court, “dead or alive.” The questions the lawyers put to the DCI on October 25, 2025, have still not received a public answer. Who does Siyad Mohamed work for? Who does Abdirahman work for? Where was the white Nissan Patrol KAU 823V that night? Who owns the black Prado TX?

When ATPU officers brandished a gun in an interrogation room, who authorized it? When NIS officers sat behind an ATPU interrogation desk, who was giving the orders? Hassan wrote a paragraph at the end of his affidavit seeking cancellation of bail—no legal jargon, no case citations. He said: “That this Honourable Court as the custodian of justice, the last line of defense in the criminal justice system cannot turn a blind eye to such grave allegations because the same can impact negatively on the administration of justice.”

Abshir’s car was towed away. The CCTV footage circulated on social media. The image of three men in tactical gear stuffing a man into an SUV played on loop. The Law Society issued a statement. Politicians expressed “deep concern.” The DCI Director said police were not involved and that investigations were ongoing. And the white Toyota Premio is still sitting in some corner of Kilimani Police Station, like an unclaimed exhibit. Its owner was last seen at four in the morning, kneeling on the tarmac of Muchai Road, in front of a gate he never managed to climb over.

Share this story
.
RECOMMENDED NEWS