✕

Abductions are assault on the Constitution

Opinion
By Peter Wena | Nov 16, 2026

Lawyers engage police officers duirng protests against the abduction of lawyer Abshir Ahmedsadak and Ayub Maalim at Jogoo House in Nairobi on November 11, 2026. [Boniface Okendo, Standard]

Abductions by Kenyan police, and the abduction of foreign dissidents on Kenyan soil with the complicity of Kenyan security agencies, are unconstitutional and unlawful.

This is not a matter of legal interpretation but a direct reading of the Constitution. Article 29 guarantees every person—citizen or foreigner—freedom and security of the person, including the right not to be deprived of freedom arbitrarily and not to be subjected to violence from either public or private sources, torture in any manner, or cruel, inhuman or degrading treatment. The use of the word "every person" is deliberate. The Constitution does not carve out an exception for suspects, for witnesses, or for people whose politics a foreign government dislikes.

 Article 25 places certain rights beyond the reach of any limitation, even in a state of emergency. Among these non-derogable rights is freedom from torture and cruel, inhuman or degrading treatment, and the right to an order of habeas corpus. This is the constitutional architecture that makes abduction impossible to justify. Habeas corpus exists precisely so that a person who has been taken and hidden can be produced before a court.

When security officers hold someone in an unrecorded facility, refuse to acknowledge the detention, or threaten a witness with fabricated terrorism charges to keep him from appearing in court, they are not merely breaking a rule.

They are attacking the one mechanism the Constitution created to prevent the state from making people disappear. Article 49(1)(f) requires that an arrested person be brought before a court as soon as reasonably possible, and in any event not later than twenty-four hours after arrest, or if that period ends outside ordinary court hours or on a day that is not an ordinary court day, the end of the next court day.

Kenyan courts have repeatedly held that detention beyond this period without a court order is a violation of the Constitution. The provision is couched in mandatory terms. Once the prescribed period lapses, the burden shifts to the State to demonstrate that the delay was reasonable and constitutionally justifiable. An abduction, by definition, bypasses this requirement entirely. There is no arrest record, no court appearance, no opportunity for a lawyer to challenge the detention.

The person is simply gone. The problem is not theoretical. The Kenya National Commission on Human Rights documented 661 complaints related to arbitrary detentions, torture, abductions and enforced disappearances between December 2024 and December 2025, including fifteen cases of abduction that the Commission described as "a worrying resurgence of tactics that have no place in a constitutional democracy".

Data from the Missing Voices Coalition cited by Amnesty International recorded six cases of enforced disappearance in Kenya in 2025, alongside 125 police killings. These are not isolated incidents by rogue officers. They are patterns. The abduction of foreign dissidents on Kenyan soil raises the same constitutional problem, compounded by the complicity of state agencies. Twaha Mwaipaya, a Tanzanian opposition activist who had fled to Kenya after being tortured in his home country, was reportedly seized in Kamulu, Machakos County, on 25 October 2026 by individuals in three vehicles. Amnesty International called for his whereabouts to be established and his safety guaranteed. The Nairobi High Court subsequently ordered the police to produce him in court "dead or alive" by 2 November 2026.

Kizza Besigye, a Ugandan opposition leader, was abducted in Nairobi on 16 November 2024, forcibly returned to Uganda, and arraigned before a military court in Kampala on 20 November 2024. The United Nations expressed "extreme concern" about the situation and urged that due process be followed and that his family and lawyers be informed of his whereabouts and condition. If Kenyan security agencies participated in, facilitated, or knowingly allowed these abductions, they violated Article 29 not because the victims were foreign nationals but because they were persons within Kenya's jurisdiction. The Constitution's protection does not depend on a passport. For ordinary Kenyans, the stakes are simple to understand. A legal system that permits abduction is not a legal system. It is a system of selective coercion.

 The Constitution's absolute prohibition on torture and its guarantee of habeas corpus were written by people who had lived through a state where people could be taken at night and never seen again. Article 25 exists because the drafters understood that once the state is allowed to disappear "bad people," the definition of "bad people" becomes whatever the state says it is. The witness threatened with terrorism charges for refusing to withdraw a fraud case is not a terrorist. He is a man who happened to know something inconvenient. The Tanzanian activist seized from a taxi is not a threat to Kenyan security. He is a refugee whose presence became diplomatically awkward.

The Constitution protects both of them for the same reason: because the alternative is a country where no one is safe. What is required is not new legislation. The Constitution already prohibits abduction. What is required is enforcement: independent investigation of every abduction report, criminal accountability for officers who hold people in unrecorded facilities or ignore court orders to produce them, and consequences for agencies that allow their facilities and vehicles to be used for intimidation. When a court orders that a person be produced "dead or alive" and the police respond that they have no record of the detention, the question that must follow is not whether the Constitution applies. It is who will be held responsible for ignoring it.

Share this story
.
RECOMMENDED NEWS